For property owners in hurricane-prone areas, choosing the right storm protection system is critical. Two of the most common options are hurricane accordion shutters and hurricane resistant (impact) windows.
Both provide strong protection, but they differ significantly in cost, convenience, appearance, and long-term value. In this guide, we’ll compare the two systems and answer a common question:
Are hurricane accordion shutters cheaper than hurricane resistant windows?
Accordion shutters are a popular storm protection solution featuring a foldable, track-mounted design. They are installed beside windows and doors and expand horizontally when deployed, then neatly fold away when not in use.
They are commonly used on patios, sliding glass doors, and large window openings.
Accordion shutters fold compactly to the sides of openings, minimizing visual impact while remaining easily accessible when needed.
Their sliding design allows for quick storm preparation, making them a convenient option during approaching storms.
Accordion shutters are commonly available in:
Material choice affects both cost and visibility while maintaining storm protection.
When closed, accordion shutters provide an additional layer of security, helping deter intruders outside of storm season.
Hurricane resistant windows—also known as impact windows—are permanent window systems designed to withstand flying debris during hurricanes. They feature laminated glass with an interlayer that holds the glass together upon impact.
Impact windows provide continuous protection without the need for deployment.
Impact windows use layered glass bonded with a polyvinyl butyral (PVB) interlayer, preventing shattering during impact.
Unlike shutters, impact windows are always protecting your home—no setup required before a storm.
Impact windows provide improved insulation, which can help reduce cooling costs and increase indoor comfort year-round.
The laminated glass construction also helps reduce outside noise, creating a quieter indoor environment.
In most cases, yes. Accordion shutters generally have a lower upfront cost compared to hurricane resistant windows, especially for larger openings.
However, total value depends on long-term benefits and usage.
Accordion shutters are often the more budget-friendly choice for immediate hurricane protection.
Impact windows typically require a higher upfront investment but offer ongoing benefits without additional setup.
When choosing between accordion shutters and impact windows, consider the following:
Accordion shutters are typically more affordable upfront, making them ideal for homeowners with budget constraints.
Impact windows offer continuous protection, energy efficiency, and noise reduction, making them a strong long-term investment.
Impact windows blend seamlessly into your home’s design, while accordion shutters are visible when not in use.
Accordion shutters require deployment before storms, while impact windows provide protection at all times.
At Lafferty Aluminum & Screening, we help Florida homeowners choose the right storm protection solutions based on real-world needs—not one-size-fits-all recommendations.
We offer:
Our goal is to help you protect your home with confidence.
Accordion shutters are generally less expensive upfront than impact windows, especially for larger openings or full-home coverage.
Yes. Impact windows provide continuous hurricane protection without the need for additional shutters.
Yes. When properly installed, accordion shutters meet hurricane impact and wind-load requirements in Florida.
Many insurance companies offer discounts for approved impact window systems. Check with your provider for eligibility.
Impact windows typically require less maintenance, while accordion shutters may need occasional cleaning, lubrication, and track inspections.
Yes. Many homeowners use impact windows on primary living areas and accordion shutters on patios or large openings to balance cost and protection.
"Lafferty did an amazing job! We love our new screen. They were very professional and we had our finished screen before expected. We recommend Lafferty to everyone."
"Lafferty did an excellent job on our unconventional screening project. The office staff was responsive and friendly. From consultation to installation, all of our questions and concerns were addressed."
"Lafferty did an excellent job installing our pool screens. The are prompt and keep you well informed concerning the job! I would definitely hire Lafferty Screens again!!"
"We are very satisfied with our new fence and work done by Lafferty Aluminum. Quality, professionalism, and reliability working with Lafferty has been very good and I am happy we chose them."
"Lafferty was one of the easiest and smoothest company's to work with. We are building our home and these guys were so customer friendly, answered all our questions, was available to take our call if we had questions."
"Friendly service, professional attitude of employee, polite and they cleaned up as they worked. We had our pool enclosed redone after hurricane damage and now it looks great. Thanks"
"Lafferty did a fantastic job from start to finish on the patio pavers and aluminum screening. They completed the project on time, and perhaps even a little ahead of schedule!"
"I couldn't be happier with the work performed by Lafferty. They replaced my original screen house in February in a professional and timely manner. I would highly recommend them for your screen enclosure needs."
We're excited to learn more about your needs and provide you with a personalized quote. Please fill out the form, and our team will get back to you with a detailed estimate to kickstart your project.
